My first Cadi🥴

I had bought my first car, 2012 Cadillac SRX, as a 17(f) from my dad's girlfriend back in April but only just signed it over on the 23rd last month. She tried selling it the past year and a half for $10,000 with just over 123,000 miles but didn't have any luck. With that same "luck" last year, she took full coverage off the car and a week later we got a massive hailstorm that practically totaled the car in hail damage. She said she had to lower the price to $5,000 because of the damage so that's what I payed for it. Apart from all the hail damage, the car had been sitting in her parking lot for over a year and barely driven, so the paint is chipping pretty bad in a lot of places and it it has a bunch of scratches and dents that aren't hail related. I love the car and am VERY thankful for having such a nice car for growing up in a not so rich family and only being 17, but I feel like $5,000 was still a bit much for the condition of the car. Am I wrong?